Do You Suffer from Overthinking? Here’s How to Break Free
This week, a friend called me sounding pretty crushed. They’d been turned down for a job and were replaying the whole thing in their head — what they said, what they should have said, and how they were “never going to deal with that company again.”
In short, they were suffering from rejection — and from overthinking.
Rejection is something we all experience, whether it’s in relationships, work, or social situations. It hurts. But what really keeps that pain alive isn’t the event itself — it’s the endless replay in your head afterward.
That’s the trap of overthinking.
What Is Overthinking (and Why Does It Feel So Exhausting)?
Overthinking happens when your brain’s problem-solving mode won’t switch off.
Maybe you recognise this:
-
You wake up at 3 AM running through tomorrow’s to-do list.
-
You can’t focus on a conversation because you’re mentally rewriting your last email.
-
You keep worrying about your child’s choices, even though you can’t change them.
Overthinking is your mind’s way of trying to create certainty and safety. But ironically, the more you think, the less peace you feel.
When you overthink, you’re not just solving problems — you’re feeding anxiety. And if it’s happening a lot, it’s usually a sign that your analytical brain has taken over and is running the show.
That’s when you start to feel constantly tense, indecisive, drained, and even stuck in a loop of worry.
But here’s the hopeful part: overthinking is a habit, and like all habits, it can be changed.
4 Practical Ways to Stop Overthinking
Breaking free from overthinking isn’t about “stopping thoughts” — it’s about changing how you relate to them. Here are four practical ways to do just that:
1. Acknowledge the Emotion Behind It
Overthinking is often an emotional response disguised as logic.
When you’re obsessing over a decision, you’re usually trying to avoid a feeling — fear, shame, disappointment, rejection.
So instead of battling your thoughts, take a moment to notice the feeling underneath.
Ask yourself:
“What emotion am I trying not to feel right now?”
Recognising the emotion helps diffuse its power — and the overthinking that follows.
2. Remember: Just Because a Thought Is True Doesn’t Mean It’s Helpful
Sometimes we convince ourselves that if a thought feels true, it must be important.
But not all thoughts deserve airtime.
If a thought makes you feel worse without offering anything useful, it’s not helping.
Instead, shift your focus to something constructive:
“What can I learn from this?” or “What’s one positive thing I can take from this situation?”
That small reframe changes your brain chemistry — and your perspective.
3. Stop Trying to Control Your Thoughts
This one’s big. The more you try to stop thinking, the more you’ll think.
Instead of fighting your thoughts, change your focus. Let them be there, but gently shift your attention to something else — your breath, your surroundings, your body.
You can’t control what pops into your head, but you can control what you feed your attention to.
That’s where calm begins.
4. Write It Down — Don’t Think It Out
If your head feels overcrowded, empty it out.
Grab a notebook and do your overthinking on paper.
Journaling slows your thoughts down, helps you see patterns, and turns a mental tornado into something you can look at objectively.
When your thoughts are written down, they lose their power to spin endlessly.
Breaking the Overthinking Cycle
Overthinking isn’t a personality flaw — it’s a coping strategy. It’s how your mind tries to manage discomfort or uncertainty. But in doing so, it often creates more of both.
With the right tools and support, you can retrain your brain to handle uncertainty without spiralling.
That’s exactly what I help clients do through Cognitive Hypnotherapy — a flexible approach combining CBT, hypnosis, and other evidence-based techniques to help calm the mind, reduce anxiety, and restore balance.
Ready to Quiet the Noise in Your Head?
If you’re stuck in a cycle of overthinking or struggling to manage anxious thoughts, you don’t have to keep doing it alone.
At Rob Donnelly Therapy, based in Newbury and Thatcham, I help clients across Berkshire learn how to think, feel, and behave differently — so they can stop living in their heads and start living their lives again.
Get in touch here to arrange a free consultation and take the first step toward peace of mind.